The case against AI-generated users - IDEO

This IDEO essay discusses concerns about AI-generated users and suggests alternatives for design research.

ideo.com/journal/the-case-against-ai-generated…
The case against AI-generated users - IDEO homepage screenshot

About The case against AI-generated users - IDEO

This 9-minute essay published January 30, 2025 argues AI-generated users cannot replace research with real people. Drawing on a rural healthcare project, it describes three weeks spent interviewing ChatGPT-created patients and practitioners, followed by a one-hour conversation with a real patient and a physician serving marginalized rural communities that proved more revealing.

Pricing is not clearly stated.

Key features

  • Contrasts participant-led tangents, unexpected insights and home or workplace context with LLM behavior
  • Describes friend and family interviews and diary studies for tight budgets

The case against AI-generated users - IDEO at a glance

Type
Publication
Platforms
Web
Details verified
Oct 23, 2026 · Official source
Language
English
Last checked
Oct 5, 2026 · Online when checked
Listed
Oct 5, 2026

Similar publications

Other listings in Articles & Essays with the most in common.

Jet New

jetnew.io

Jet New shares notes and essays about the author’s learning, ideas, and projects.

Publication

🔭 The Einstein AI model

thomwolf.io/blog/scientific-ai.html

Thomas Wolf reflects on whether AI will bring a compressed 21st century in this essay about the Einstein AI model.

Publication

Popular in Articles & Essays

Well-known listings from the same topic.

All 40

The case against AI-generated users - IDEO FAQ

What does the essay report about the ethics of synthetic users?
It reports asking ChatGPT about the ethics, which answered that users provide qualitative feedback, emotions and insights synthetic users cannot replicate, and overuse might miss important human factors in design.
Is something wrong or out of date?

Tell us and an editor will check it.

Own this website?

Claim the listing and suggest updates yourself. An editor checks every claim first.

Claim this listing